Row erupts after councillor blasts campaign to knit hats for troops in Afghanistan

Bury Times: Jonny Ball wears a hat he received while on duty in Afghanistan. Jonny Ball wears a hat he received while on duty in Afghanistan.

A Bury councillor has sparked controversy by criticising a knitting campaign which provides hats to troops in Afghanistan.

Labour councillor Joanne Columbine was accused of “political point-scoring” when she took a swipe at the Wel Hats campaign, which is run by Conservative councillors in Welwyn Hatfield, Hertfordshire, and local Conservative MP Grant Shapps.

Campaign organiser Jonny Ball said Cllr Columbine, who represents Ramsbottom, sent him an e-mail “out of the blue” criticising the campaign because it is linked to the government.

Cllr Columbine wrote: “Knitted hats aren't going to help those who need support – good public services would do that.

“Ironic then that your organisation is associated with a government that is systematically forcing hardworking families into poverty, and then removing the support systems that they need to live with dignity.”

Residents and local businesses in the area have been involved and helped to knit hats, which were then sent to servicemen and women.

Mr Ball, who served in Afghanistan in 2012, says friends who are on their last tour of the country have been “saddened” to hear of Cllr Columbine’s comments.

He said: “We’ve had people young and old knit, from all sections of our community, backed by our local paper and backed by people from all political colours.

“It is therefore doubly sad, as someone who received a hat myself whilst serving out there, that this lady has used this charitable effort to attack her political foes.

"Is this not what turns people off of politics in the first place? Our campaign has brought people together, where she has sought to divide, and this simply isn’t acceptable.

“What this knitting campaign has shown us, is that community spirit is alive and well, and the dozens of thank you letters from Helmand reflect the power of this morale boosting effort.”

Mr Ball said he did not initially know that the writer was a Labour councillor, as she did not declare this in her e-mail, but discovered it after searching her email address on the internet.

The campaign has seen 3,000 hats knitted for troops, and they have received around 50 letters from Helmand in appreciation of their efforts.

Mr Ball said knows how the scheme can benefit troops as he received a hat himself while serving in Afghanistan, which influenced the formation of the campaign.

He added: “It all started with my aunt knitting a hat for me during a very cold winter tour of Afghanistan and soon developed into something much larger as my aunt and her WI friends sent out more and more hats for the boys and girls.

“By the end of the tour, my entire Patrol Base had warm heads, thanks to the kindness of others, and letters were sent back and forth between home and Helmand.”

Cllr Columbine refused to comment.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:52pm Mon 13 Jan 14

Babbar Divino says...

I think it would be useful to see the full correspondence that was sent as I "hope" this might be taken out of context.

Regardless I hope voters in Rammy will think twice if this Cllr puts her name up for re-election.
I think it would be useful to see the full correspondence that was sent as I "hope" this might be taken out of context. Regardless I hope voters in Rammy will think twice if this Cllr puts her name up for re-election. Babbar Divino
  • Score: 7

8:49am Tue 14 Jan 14

Yellow Hackle says...

Perhaps Cllr Columbine would be better off having a trip over to Afghanistan
in the bitterly cold weather ( Funded by herself of course ) then she might understand how much comfort these Knitted hats help moral.
I do understand what Cllr Columbine is getting at! There are too many Ex-service personnel living on the streets and benefits being denied to them
due to the cut-backs being made by the Conservatives ( Or I hope that's what she is aiming at Lol )
Perhaps Cllr Columbine would be better off having a trip over to Afghanistan in the bitterly cold weather ( Funded by herself of course ) then she might understand how much comfort these Knitted hats help moral. I do understand what Cllr Columbine is getting at! There are too many Ex-service personnel living on the streets and benefits being denied to them due to the cut-backs being made by the Conservatives ( Or I hope that's what she is aiming at Lol ) Yellow Hackle
  • Score: 2

11:29am Tue 14 Jan 14

old scroat says...

My god! Another politician standing up and being counted. Obviously not very popular with those who still believe in the Empire though.
My god! Another politician standing up and being counted. Obviously not very popular with those who still believe in the Empire though. old scroat
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree